September 10, 2002


Max
(Lions Gate Films) Rated NYR


 

Starring: Noah Taylor, John Cusack, Leelee Sobieski,
Paul Hipp, Molly Parker
Directed by: Menno Meyjes
Written by: Menno Meyjes

Wow.  I didn’t know what to expect.  The buzz in the air was that this was a comedic, sometimes dramatic look at the evolution of Adolph Hitler, played by Noah Taylor.  Well, it was more like a dramatic, occasionally comedic look at Hitler and his relationship with Max Rothman, a jewish art dealer of such notables as Max Ernst, Paul Klee and Georg Grosz. 

I don’t want to tell you too much, but the thing that really took me by surprise about this film was how gentle and lovely and emotionally complex this journey was.  Max has only one arm, having lost his right arm in service for his country.  He has his own shattered dreams and challenging aspirations to deal with before Hitler stumbles into his life.  And so begins the waltz for both men.  Nothing is obvious, yet nothing has that feel of a film trying to be different for the sake of its own preciousness. 

Cusack is at the top of his game as a man of breeding, taste and real caring.  Noah Taylor has his career-best role and hits it out of the park.  And supporting actresses Leelee Sobieski and Molly Parker shine… especially Sobieski, who convincingly plays a post-teen woman for the first time I remember.  

Menno Meyjes, who has had a very successful career as a screenwriter, does a solid job behind the camera, never getting caught trying too hard or missing any of the basic rules of filmmaking.  Actually, that’s damning with too-faint praise.  He does an excellent job.  He’s not a style guy and he doesn’t quite have the strokes of Brad Silberling or White Oleander’s Peter Kosminsky.  But really nice work.  And, as a writer of an original script, he’s almost like the sane version of Charlie Kaufman.  His work provokes, but never chafes. 

I’m looking forward to seeing Max again and again.  I don’t have the passion for it that I have for City of God, but I can feel it staying with me… and it lingers still…

 

 

 

©2002 The Hot Button.com
All Rights Reserved.